专栏名称: 哲学园
哲学是爱智慧, 爱智慧乃是对心灵的驯化。 这里是理念的在场、诗意的栖居地。 关注哲学园,认识你自己。
目录
相关文章推荐
哲学王  ·  刘擎讲尼采:重估一切价值 ·  13 小时前  
慧田哲学  ·  鲜为人知的毛泽东与蒋介石 ·  14 小时前  
政治哲学研究  ·  新书速递 | 弗洛伊德的步伐 ·  4 天前  
哲学王  ·  鲜为人知的毛泽东与蒋介石 ·  昨天  
51好读  ›  专栏  ›  哲学园

奎因哲学词条:信念

哲学园  · 公众号  · 哲学  · 2025-01-02 00:00

正文

请到「今天看啥」查看全文


是个语法上的不及物动词。

Believing is a disposition. Thinking, apart from the contexts that and so , is an activity, however sedentary. We could tire ourselves out thinking, if we put our minds to it, but believing [19]takes no toll. We sit and think, but do we sit and believe? The White Queen, indeed, professed to do so: "When I was your age, I always did it for half-an-hour a day. Why, sometimes I've believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast. " But it will be agreed that the White Queen was atypical.

Believing (相信)是一种倾向。而在不后接 “that” “so” 的语境中, thinking (想)却是一种活动,尽管它并不涉及身体的运动。我们也许会疲劳不堪,如果我们全神贯注地想的话。但相信却不费吹灰之力。我们可以坐下来想,但我们会坐下来相信吗?白王后声称她就是这样做的: 我像你这么大年纪的时候,每天都要练上半个钟头。有时我会在早餐前就已相信了六个之多的不可能的事情。 但大家都认为,白王后并没有典型性。

She represented beliefs, some of them anyway, as voluntary activities rather than dispositions. She was wrong about their being activities; they are dispositions. But we may still ask whether they are ever voluntary, for some dispositions are. We are voluntarily acquiring a disposition, or trying to, when we memorize "II Penseroso" or the multiplication table or make a New Year's resolution. Belief, however, is not that kind of a disposition. To speak of simply deciding to believe something, independently of any evidence real or imagined, is to stretch the term 'belief' beyond belief.

她把信念(至少其中的一些)描述为主动的活动而非倾向。这是错的,因为信念是倾向而不是活动。但我们仍可以问:信念可以是主动的倾向吗?有些倾向确实是主动的。当我们背诵诗歌 忧郁的人 Il Penseroso )或乘法表,或制定新年计划时,我们就是在主动地或努力地获得一种倾向。不过,信念并不属于这类倾向。有人谈起信念时,仿佛它们可以招之即来、挥之即去,一切都取决于我们当下的决定,而根本用不着考虑(真实或想像的)证据;我只能说,他们所说的所谓信念已越出了 信念 这个词的外延了。

An enamored (迷恋的) young man has his reasons for subscribing to the tenets of his fiancee's church, and a heretic (异教徒) threatened by the Inquisition (宗教裁判所) had his reasons for a similar move; but these are cases of feigning







请到「今天看啥」查看全文